The Lemon Tree is Dead: A Visit To the Mixed Cities Project

On October 30, we visited the offices of the Mixed Cities Project in Ramle,  only one block from the location of the now famous home in Sandy Tolan’s “The Lemon Tree.” The lemon tree is now just a dead stump in the play area of the children’s center into which the house was converted.

defaultdefaultdefault

The Lemon Tree Home: Front The Lemon Tree Backyard Sandbox on top of Lemon Tree Stump

The Mixed Cities Project was launched in 2003 by SHATIL, the New Israel Fund’s Empowerment and Training Center for Social Change Organizations in Israel, with support from the European Union. The Project seeks to empower Palestinian residents in Ramle, Lod, Acco, Jaffa and Haifa to fight for equal access to housing rights, spatial, cultural and overall civic equality and to participate and gain representation in public planning at national, regional and local levels.

We met with Buthayna Dabit, the Director of the Project, and we toured the neglected Palestinian neighborhoods of Lod. Palestinians constitute close to 20% of Israel’s population and live mainly in all Palestinian Arab towns and villages. 90,000 Palestinians live in the mixed cities listed above, but live in isolated, separate and neglected neighborhoods that exist under oppressive spatial constraints and in poverty and without the most basic elements of normal infrastructure such as sewage, refuse disposal, surfaced access roads and street lighting. Israeli planning authorities refuse routine building and planning permits that force Palestinian families to make necessary repairs to homes and businesses that often result in demolition orders that are carried out by Israeli police in the same military fashion as the army in the oPt. Many of the Palestinian neighborhoods are “unrecognized” and are ignored when major highways, rail routes and industrial zones are planned.

Municipalities also facilitate the erosion of Palestinian and Arab cultural identity by refusing to post streets and municipal buildings with Arabic language and by ignoring the need to preserve Palestinian cultural sites in what are known as the “old cities” in the mixed city neighborhoods. These “old city” locations were both the original population centers of the formerly exclusive Palestinian villages and the locations where Palestinians from the villages were forcibly “transferred” in 1948 into small neighborhoods that were then surrounded by fences and referred to as “ghettos”. Now, in some neighborhoods, the Israeli planning authorities have built walls, that look very much like the “Apartheid Wall” inside the West Bank, to separate the Palestinian population from the Jewish residents.

For more information about the Project and the details of the ongoing discrimination against Palestinian citizens of Israel in the mixed cities, please visit www.nif.org.il or contact Ms. Dabit at [email protected].

defaultdefaultdefault

Inside 1948 Home: Outside 1948 Home Parking Lot Built and 1948 Homes Destroyed

 

 
  • »Permalink
  • 2 Comments
  • Posted by:howardlenow

Dr. Hanna Swaid, Palestinian MK Knesset

On Monday, October 29, Jeff Klein and I met with Dr. Hanna Swaid, Palestinian Israeli Member of the Knesset from the Hadash party, in his Knesset office.  Dr. Swaid framed his overall comments by explaining that the Occupation is the root of Israel’s conflicts with the world and with its Palestinian citizens.  He believes that the only hope, if there is any, is for the imposition of an international occupation in place of the Israeli occupation.  He does not believe in waiting for a negotiated settlement on the terms of a Palestinian state because he does not believe it will happen so long as Israel controls the West Bank and Gaza.  He believes that only after an international solution is imposed, will the details of final status negotiations be possible.

Dr. Swaid also said that the long debate about Israel’s security is no longer a military one, but a demographic one.  He is deeply concerned that forces within Israel have adopted this shift in framing the concept of security for Israel and that Palestinian citizens of Israel are under the most significant threat ever.  He suggests that the manner in which the Knesset is talking about the “Arab Minority” says everything about the country’s view of the minority as less than citizens and the next true threat to the Jewish State.  He points to the recent vote of 65-13 in favor of the new legislation prohibited the sale of JNF lands to non-jews as evidence that not only Israel, but the world’s Jewish community, is prepared to institutionalize the legitimacy of discrimination against Israel’s Palestinian citizens rather than simply maintaining the defacto practices of discrimination that characterize almost every aspect of life for Palestinians within Israel.

He is also disheartened by the lack of political involvement by the Palestinian community within Israel.  He points to declining voter turnout by the Arab Minority, even in the face of the most serious threat to civil rights in years.  He believes that the recent effort by Israel to publicize “Arab National Service” as a substitute for military service as a cynical effort to fool the world into believing that Israel is seeking real options for the Arab minority.  While Israel claims that “national service” will allow the Arab minority to gain some of the benefits that come with military service, he suggests that the program is a sham and does not even come close to establishing equivalent civil rights and benefits.  When he tries to get details about the program, he is told that the details are “classified” and controlled by the Ministry of Defense.  He says that if Israel was truly interested in providing equal rights, the Arab Minority should be able to define how to deploy national service within the Palestinian communities to build a better infrastructure, support education and other social services.

One final note:  It took us longer to enter the Knesset than to cross the Huwara checkpoint in Nablus.  The security staff was stymied as to why we, American Jews were meeting with an “Arab” Knesset Minister.  I was careless because I forgot that I was carrying all of the literature that I had collected in the West Bank, including man maps and flyers put out by Al Mubadara, one of the independent parties within Palestine.  When they took out my maps that showed the division of the West Bank into Bantustans, they went running around for higher level security personnel thinking I was intending to distribute the flyers inside the Knessset building.  They refused to let us bring in cameras of recording equipment, but, for some reason, let me bring in my laptop, that has the ability to take photos and record sound and video.  So, the picture below of Dr. Swaid, was my quite resistance activity for the day and a violation of the Knesset security procedures.
default
 
  • »Permalink
  • Write comment
  • Posted by:howardlenow

"How Do I Paint A Watermelon" :Sulelman Monsour and the Ramallah Arts Academy

On Wednesday, October 24, several  members of the delegation met with Sulelman Monsour, one of the founders of the Modern Palestinian Arts Movement.  As with all of our meetings in Palestine, every aspect of Palestinian life has been profoundly impacted by the Occupation.  Sulelman is not the Director of the Ramallah Arts Academy in Ramallah, the first post secondary school in Palestine dedicated to exploring creative visual arts.  Sulelman's personal history to generate a free and expressive traditon of visual art is a history of struggle.  He dates the beginning of the Palestinian Arts movement to 1967 when any posting or efforts to display Palestinian art was prohibited.  In 1972, he tried to organize the first Visual Arts Exhibit by creating  a Palestinian Artists Union. He was required to gain a permit to establish the Union, but it was denied by Israeli Military authorities.  Finally, in 1975, he was able to hold the first Palestinian Arts exhibition.  He told us that the Israeli Army showed up at the exhibition taking pictures of the art and writing down the artists names.  THis was followed by vists by the army to the artists homes and continued harassment.  By 1979, the army closed down any continuing art exhibitions and orders that no Palestinian painters could use the colors green, red, white and black together.  Sulelman said that when he received these orders, he simply asked "With these restrictions, how do I paint a watermelon?"

After the first intifada, he told us that Palestinian artists adopted a voluntary code to stop using any Israeli products for their work.  They began using only materials they could find in Palestine which led him to working with mud as his media, while other artists found creative expression in olive wood leather and using colors made from dyes found in native plants.  He joked that while he created many works in mud, the market for sales in this media never materialized.

 Along with other artists, Sulelman lobbied for years to establish an arts program at Bir Zeit University.  He explained that the Israeli Military authorities refused to allow two types of programs at Bir Zeit, one was agriculture, and the other was art.

With funding from Norway and the tireless lobbying and fundraising of Maria Khouri, the Ramallah Arts Academy opened its doors in 2006 with its first class of 10 students.  DSC01668.JPGDSC01677.JPG

 
  • »Permalink
  • Write comment
  • Posted by:howardlenow

Ali Jiddah and African Palestinians in Jerusalem

Two of our delegation members had the distinct pleasure of meeting with Ali JIddah in his home in the African Quarter today.  Ali Jiddah is one of the leaders of the AFrican Palestinian community in Jerusalem who is unfortunately suffering from ill health from complications from diabetes.  He shared a short video interview that was produce by an American television reporter that we hope to put up on the HaHRP web site upon our return.  After spending 17 years in Israeli prisons, he has spent his life advocating for Palestinian nationalism and recognition of the rights of African Palestinians.  He has a keen sense of the need for a renewed non-violent grassroots movement among Palestinians, but is concerned that the Isareli endgame of separating Palestinians from each other has been too successful.  Please check back for his video interview.
 
  • »Permalink
  • 1 Comments
  • Posted by:howardlenow

Meeting with the Palestinian Negotiating Project and Dr. Saeb Erekat

defaultOn Thursday, several members of our delegation met with members of the Palestinian Negotiating Project. First, we met with Wassim Khazmo, an attorney, who advises the PLO to prepare for negotiations. We also met with the the Chief of Staff for President Abbas and Dr. Saeb Erekat, the PLO's chief negotiator. The main topic of their presentations were the preparations and strategy for the potential summitt that may take place in Annapolis in November. Generally, the great concern is that Israel is not approaching these meetings with any real intent of making progress or any real intentions of making proposals that will be even close to acceptable to the PLO. When we asked Dr. Erekat about the potential for creating a new mythology that Israel came to the table and the Palestinians walked away like in Camp David, he told us that he had this very conversation with Tzippi Livni. He said that she promised him she would never blame him if the negotiations failed. He said that he told her, "I have been in this movie before" meaning that the same claim and promise was made at Camp David by President Clinton and within hours of the failed talks, Clinton issued a statement blaming the Palestinians. Many of the people with whom we have spoken are very worried that another failed negotiation process could lead to an even greater sense of hopelessness on the street and that a third intifada is a real possibility.
 
  • »Permalink
  • Write comment
  • Posted by:howardlenow
Blog-List
21Publish - Cooperative Publishing